Cloudflare says the Swiss non-profit Quad9 announced last month that it will withdraw its free public DNS resolver, 9.9.9.9, from France. According to Cloudflare's blog post, the decision followed months of litigation and a French court ruling that imposed daily financial penalties on Quad9 for not blocking domains tied to alleged copyright infringement. [1]
Cloudflare argues that Quad9, which offers only a resolver, had no other way to show compliance with the order, leaving it to choose between altering its service or leaving the country. By contrast, Cloudflare says a French court rejected penalties against it for not blocking through 1.1.1.1, finding that steps taken through its CDN and reverse-proxy service were sufficient. [1]
The practical risk, as Cloudflare describes it, is that Quad9's privacy-focused design means it does not know who uses its resolver and cannot notify them. Cloudflare says French users include government bodies, schools, hospitals and utilities, and that anyone who has not switched resolvers before the service ends will see lookups fail without explanation. It adds that devices hardwired to Quad9, such as security systems or thermostats, may be slow or impossible to fix. [1]
Administrators in France who rely on 9.9.9.9 can avoid disruption by changing resolver settings in advance; Cloudflare notes that switching resolvers is straightforward. The post does not give a date for when Quad9's service will stop. [1]
Cloudflare frames the case as part of a wider push by rightsholders. It says Cisco previously withdrew OpenDNS from France and Portugal, and temporarily from Belgium, and that a Belgian court has ordered Cloudflare, Google and Cisco to begin blocking sites through their public resolvers by early January 2027 or face substantial penalties. Cloudflare says it has never blocked via 1.1.1.1 and that the three companies have appealed, hoping for a resolution before year end. [1]
Cloudflare's broader case is that resolver-level blocking is ineffective, since users can switch resolvers or use IP addresses directly, and that it causes collateral damage because it blocks whole domains and gives users no notice. It says courts in Germany previously ruled for Cloudflare and Quad9 against blocking demands. These are the positions of a party to related litigation, and the post includes no response from rightsholders. [1]